Paw paw lake vacation rentals

Looking to rent out your home as a vacation rental on Paw Paw Lake? Look no further! Windy Mitten Properties provides local and dedicated service for your home when you're not there. We understand your property deserves the utmost care when being rented out, so we've designated our team of dedicated staff members, housekeeping and contractors to provide top notch service for your home. 

Earn income while you're not there, knowing your property is in good hands.

Allow us to coordinate with renters creating a hassle free experience for property owners.

With staff conveniently located right on Paw Paw Lake, you should be rest assured renters in your home will be tended to in a timely manner. 

By partnering with Windy Mitten Properties, homeowners can count on us to:

* Show their property to interested renters 

* Communicate with renters: ensuring collection of signed lease, security deposit and rental fee

* Meet guests at property upon arrival 

* Provide concierge service to guests with recommendations to local sights, restaurants and happenings

* 24 hour emergency service availability for unexpected needs

* Cleaning/housekeeping services 

Other perks of partnering with us include:

* Access to boat rides, cruises on Paw Paw Lake with a licensed boat operator

To speak with a dedicated staff member or for a property consultation, contact us today!

Featured Listings:

The Blue Rooster


The Blue Rooster on Paw Paw Lake boasts 69ft of lake frontage with a brand new kitchen, remodeled bathroom, bedrooms and new flooring. Have a seat in the sunroom and take in the amazing views this perfect cottage has to offer. Huge yard large enough to accommodate games, outdoor seating and extra parking. Comfortably sleeps 7.

The Ellinee Bay Beach House


Welcome to the Ellinee Bay Beach House! This amazing Paw Paw Lake getaway boasts gorgeous views of the lake from all three levels. The Ellinee Bay Beach House has it all - 3 bedrooms and 3 baths with the master bedroom and oversized bathroom on its own floor. Two sets of washer/dryers, and a second kitchen in the walkout basement make this home ideal for a large family gathering and for entertaining. Whether you’re enjoying a meal on the upper deck, taking in the sunset from the screened in porch or hanging out in the large yard, you’ll be sure to enjoy every ounce of this home and its beauty. Comfortably sleeps 11.

The Reliable Retreat


The Reliable Retreat is one of Paw Paw Lake’s most charming properties. Situated on a lot with 80 feet of lake frontage, the retreat boasts 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with easy access to the boat dock and water entry. With a beautiful yard and gorgeous views of the lake, this recently updated old-time cottage is the perfect gem for a group looking to enjoy everything PPL has to offer. 

The Big Red Cottage


The Big Red Cottage boasts one of the most beautiful properties on Paw Paw Lake. This 5 bedroom, 2 bathroom rustic cottage sits on a huge lakefront property and can sleep 8 people. It is the perfect place for a large group to gather and enjoy "lake life". With a large yard for activities and a massive wrap around screened in porch to accommodate everyone, this is the perfect place to gather and really enjoy the old time feel this historical home built in 1880 has to offer. Owned by current family since 1925!

The Tree House


Welcome to the Tree House – a private relaxing spot in the trees overlooking beautiful Paw Paw Lake! The Tree House has been cherished by the same family for over four generations – but was recently updated with fresh paint, new beds, and refinished hardwood floors. Enjoy fun yard games in the shady yard, have a cocktail or coffee on the sunny deck, and give yourself the opportunity to relax in this comfortable and clean oasis. The Tree House has access to the lake via the community beach just steps down the hill. The Tree House offers 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with an option to accommodate two more with a queen blow up mattress, sleeping a total of 9. Come enjoy all Paw Paw Lake has to offer from up in the trees! 

The Maple Cottage


Welcome to the Maple Cottage! A charming and eclectic family vacation home located on the channels of beautiful Paw Paw Lake! This spacious lakehouse has it all – 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, huge family room, large yard perfect for games and play, and a newly remodeled deck to relax in the quaint atmosphere. As you walk in, you'll notice the vibrant lake house decor from around the world. Paintings and ceramics from Italy, figurines and tablecloths from Kenya, and a unique, tree bark dining table from Ecuador's Amazonian basin. Plenty of space for a large family to enjoy the beauty of Paw Paw Lake. Comfortably sleeps 14. 

The Sanssouci

The Sanssouci is one of Paw Paw Lake's most ideal rental homes. With over 3,000 sq. ft and room to sleep 12 guests, this home boasts some of the most spectacular views of the lake and it's breathtaking sunsets. With 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, this home could easily accommodate several families. Just steps down from the walkout basement is access to the pier with room for one spot to park your boat.